Inventorying Your Monitoring Tools: The Overlap Map
You cannot fix a pile you cannot see. I have sat in a meeting where the agenda said "consolidate monitoring" and nobody at the table could say how many monitoring tools there were. (The guesses ran from four to eleven. Eleven was right.) Before anyone talks about consolidating, migrating, or switching anything off, you need one document. For every monitoring tool you own, it must answer what it watches, who owns it, and who actually uses it. It must also answer what it costs, where its alerts go, and what would break if it vanished. Most teams have never written this down. Most teams are surprised, when they finally do, by how many tools appear on the list.
This guide walks you through building that document in two layers. The first is the tool inventory: one record per tool, with a fixed set of fields. The second is the overlap-and-gap matrix: a grid with things-to-watch as rows and tools as columns. Each cell says whether that tool is the primary way you watch that thing, a secondary, or nothing at all. The matrix is the one page every later decision in this series rests on. It shows you which tools are pulling their weight, which are redundant, and, most importantly, which rows have no tool at all.
You will also learn how to find the tools you forgot you had, because there are always some. And you will see a worked example with anonymous tools, so you know what a finished matrix looks like before you build your own. Budget an afternoon for the first pass and a week of "oh, and that one" corrections afterward. The corrections are not a sign you did the first pass badly. They are the inventory working.
In this guide
- What the inventory is for
- Step 1: One record per tool
- Step 2: Finding the surprise tools
- Step 3: Building the overlap-and-gap matrix
- Step 4: Reading the matrix
- A worked example
- Keeping it alive
- Where to go next
What the inventory is for
The inventory is not paperwork for its own sake. It exists to make three decisions possible. First, what to keep: a tool that is the only thing watching something important is not going anywhere until a replacement is proven. Second, what to retire: a tool that only duplicates what others already do is a candidate. Third, what to add: a row with nothing in it is a gap, and gaps are where outages hide. Without the inventory, these decisions get made by whoever argues loudest. That usually means the tool with the most attached feelings survives regardless of its usefulness.
The inventory also has a quieter benefit. Writing "owner: unknown" next to a tool that sends alerts every night is a small, clarifying shock. It is much harder to leave that blank once it is on a page that other people can see.
Step 1: One record per tool
Start with the tools you already know about; the forgotten ones come in step 2. For each, fill in the fields below. Keep it in whatever your team will actually maintain, which is usually a spreadsheet or a page in the team wiki. The format matters far less than the discipline of filling every field. A blank field is itself information. Nobody knows the retention, meaning how long the tool keeps its history? That is a finding. So do not skip fields that are hard. Write "unknown" and move on.
| Field | What to write | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Name and kind | What people call it, plus its role: general monitoring platform, vendor's own console, log platform, flow collector, external uptime checker, script | The kind tells you what it could do; the name tells you what people mean when they say "check the tool" |
| What it watches | Device classes (switches, servers, APs, UPS, printers), metric types (up/down, CPU, disk, interface traffic), logs, flows, synthetic checks (fake user actions such as loading a page) | Becomes the column of the matrix |
| Owner | One named person who is responsible for it | A tool without an owner has nobody to say yes to retiring it, and nobody to fix it |
| Users | Who actually logs in, and how often (daily, during incidents, never) | "Never" is the most common answer and the most useful |
| Cost in effort | Hours per month to keep it running: patching, tuning, adding devices, chasing false alarms | Effort is a real cost that never appears on a renewal invoice |
| Cost in renewal | Whether it is licensed, what the renewal is tied to (device count, users, data volume), and when notice must be given | You need the notice date long before you need the amount |
| Alerts sent, and to whom | Every notification path: email addresses, distribution lists, chat channels, phone numbers, ticket queues | The addresses that no longer belong to anyone are the silent failures |
| Data retention | How long it keeps history, and whether that history is used for anything (capacity reports, evidence for the ISP, audits) | Decides what must be exported before it is switched off |
| Integration points | What sends data to it and what it sends data to: agents, syslog, webhooks, scripts, ticketing, other tools | Each integration is a thing that breaks when the tool goes away |
| Where it runs | Server or service, credentials it holds, agents it has installed elsewhere | Needed for decommissioning later, and for the security review you have been putting off |
Two of these deserve a word. Owner must be one person, not a group. A group does not answer email. And alerts sent, and to whom is the field most likely to contain a surprise. Log into each tool, open its notification settings, and copy every address exactly. You will find distribution lists that no longer exist and personal addresses of people who left. You will also find at least one channel that was muted years ago by everyone in it.
Step 2: Finding the surprise tools
Every inventory built from memory is incomplete, because the most dangerous tools are the ones nobody remembers as tools. Here is where to look for them. Each of these sources takes a few minutes and each usually turns up something.
- Expense and renewal records. Ask finance for anything recurring that mentions monitoring, alerting, uptime, logging, status pages, or an unfamiliar vendor name paid by card. The trial that became permanent lives here.
- DNS query logs. Your internal resolvers know every hostname your servers talk to. Search the logs for names containing words like
monitor,agent,telemetry,collector,metrics, orstatus. A server that resolves a monitoring service's hostname every minute has an agent talking to it, whether or not anyone remembers installing one. - Installed services and agents. On each server, list the running services and look for anything that phones home. Unfamiliar service names, especially ones containing "agent," are worth a search.
- Scheduled tasks and cron jobs. The "just for now" scripts live here. Examples are a task that pings a list of hosts and sends mail, a job that checks certificate dates, or a script that copies a log somewhere.
- Firewall rules. Outbound rules that allow specific servers to reach specific outside addresses were created for a reason. Some of those reasons are monitoring services.
- Mail rules and shared mailboxes. A mailbox called something like "alerts" or "noc" with thousands of unread messages is both a tool and a finding.
- SNMP configuration on devices. The list of allowed management addresses on your switches tells you exactly which pollers are asking them questions. Anything on that list that is not in your inventory is either a forgotten tool or a security problem. You want to know which.
- Ask the help desk. They know which status page they read to callers, and it is often not the one you think.
The service check is quick to script. On a Windows server, a single line lists services with suspicious names. Run it across a handful of representative servers and compare the results with your list.
Get-Service | Where-Object { $_.DisplayName -match 'agent|monitor|collector|telemetry|beat' } |
Select-Object Name, DisplayName, Status
Get-ScheduledTask | Where-Object { $_.TaskName -match 'ping|check|monitor|alert|uptime' } |
Select-Object TaskName, TaskPath, State
On Linux hosts, systemctl list-units --type=service and a look through /etc/cron.d and each user's crontab do the same job. You are not trying to be exhaustive on every host. You are trying to find the kinds of surprise that exist. That way, you know what to add to the inventory and then hunt for everywhere.
At Northgate Retail the inventory from memory listed five tools. The DNS logs listed six: a hostname, monitor2.example.com, that every server in the old data centre resolved once a minute. It was a monitoring server nobody had logged into for two years. It was still polling forty hosts and still paging an engineer who had left. The mobile number it was paging had since been reassigned. The person who now owned that number had been receiving "DISK CRITICAL" texts at three in the morning and had assumed they were a scam. The server is now in the inventory with a real owner, and the texts have stopped. The new owner of the number has been sent an apology and, at their request, nothing else.
Tip: when you find a surprise tool, resist the urge to turn it off on the spot. Add it to the inventory with "owner: unknown" and "users: unknown" and keep going. A surprise tool is, by definition, one whose dependencies you do not yet understand. The guide on sunsetting a tool gracefully exists precisely because "it was just a script" has taken down more than one backup schedule.
Step 3: Building the overlap-and-gap matrix
With the tool list complete, build the matrix. The rows are the things you need to watch, expressed as capabilities. That means not "the core switch" but "core switches: up/down," "core switches: interface errors," "core switches: configuration change." The best source for the rows is your device inventory. If you do not have a trustworthy one, building a device inventory is the place to start. Cross that inventory with the handful of check types that matter for each device class. The columns are your tools, one column each.
Each cell gets one of four marks:
- P (primary): this is the tool you actually rely on for this row. Its alert is the one someone acts on. There should be exactly one P per row.
- S (secondary): this tool also watches this row, but nobody relies on it. It may alert, it may graph, but if it went quiet nobody would notice for a while.
- U (unused): this tool could watch this row, and may even be licensed for it, but it is not configured to. This mark is how you find hidden capacity in tools you already own.
- blank: this tool cannot do this, or it is irrelevant here.
Be strict about P. If you find yourself wanting to put two Ps on one row, that is not a tie. It is a row where nobody has decided. The incident where two tools disagree lives there. Pick one, or write "P?" and take it to the team. Be equally strict about the difference between S and U. A secondary is doing the work and being ignored, while an unused capability has never been switched on. They lead to different decisions.
Filling the cells is faster with a small trick: do not fill the matrix from memory. Fill it from the tools. Open each tool in turn, walk down the rows, and mark what it is actually configured to watch, not what it could watch in principle. Then look at every row that ended up with more than one mark. For each, ask the person who responds to that kind of problem a single question: "when this breaks, which tool's alert do you act on?" Their answer is the P. The others are S. You will be surprised how often the answer is "neither, someone phones me," which is a row with no P wearing a disguise.
Step 4: Reading the matrix
A finished matrix reads like a map, and there are five patterns to look for. Read the columns first, then the rows.
Columns with only S marks: retirement candidates
A tool whose entire column is secondaries does nothing that some other tool is not already primary for. Nobody would notice if it went quiet. It is the strongest possible candidate for retirement, and the inventory's "users" field will usually confirm that nobody logs in.
Columns with one unique P: specialists to keep
A tool that is primary for one or two rows nobody else can cover, and blank everywhere else, is a specialist. It is not sprawl, and it is not a candidate. Note it, and make sure its P rows are known to whoever owns the anchor platform. That is the one general tool you intend to build the rest around. The point of making those rows known is to keep them from being accidentally "consolidated" into nothing. (The quotation marks are load-bearing.)
Rows with no P: the gaps
A row with only S and U marks, or nothing at all, is a gap. Nobody is reliably watching this. These rows are the reason to do the inventory at all. They usually cluster around the boundaries between teams: the UPS, the printers, the branch router, the certificate on the internal portal, the storage array's management interface.
Rows with several S marks and a P: the noise
A row where one tool is primary and three others are secondary is being watched four times. Every one of those secondaries may be alerting, polling the device, and applying its own threshold. These rows are where alert noise and duplicated polling come from, and where the earliest consolidation wins are.
U marks under a strong column: free coverage
If one column has many Ps and also several Us, that tool could close some of your gaps without buying anything. This is the cheapest finding in the whole exercise: coverage you already own and never switched on. It is also the one finding that never appears in a vendor's slide deck.
A worked example
Here is a matrix for a fictional mid-sized organization with four tools. Tool A is a general monitoring platform the network team runs. Tool B is the switch vendor's own management console. Tool C is an external uptime checker a web project set up. Tool D is a server agent tool that started as a trial. The rows are a representative slice, not the full estate (everything the organization is responsible for watching).
| Capability (row) | Tool A general platform | Tool B vendor console | Tool C uptime checker | Tool D server agents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Core switches: up/down | P | S | ||
| Core switches: interface errors | S | P | ||
| Core switches: config change | P | |||
| Wireless APs: up/down | U | P | ||
| Servers: up/down | P | S | S | |
| Servers: disk, CPU, memory | S | P | ||
| Windows services running | U | P | ||
| Public website from outside | P | |||
| Certificate expiry | U | S | ||
| Internet link latency and loss | P | S | ||
| Branch routers: up/down | U | |||
| UPS: on battery, runtime | U | |||
| Printers: up/down, consumables | U | |||
| Log search |
Now read it with the five patterns. Tool C's column has exactly one P, the outside-in view of the public website, which no internal tool can provide. That is a specialist. But its two S marks (servers up/down, internet link) are noise. It is alerting on internal things that Tool A already owns, and those alerts should be switched off, not the tool. Tool D's column is primary for two real rows, so it cannot simply be retired. But its "servers up/down" secondary duplicates Tool A and is a source of contradictory alerts. Whether Tool D stays long-term depends on whether Tool A's unused capabilities (the U marks in the services row) could take over its Ps. That is a question for a trial, not a guess.
Tool B is a specialist for interface errors, configuration change, and the wireless detail. Keep it. But notice that "wireless APs: up/down" has its P in the vendor console and only a U in the general platform. That means the only "access point down" alert comes from a console nobody watches at night. That P should probably move.
Then the rows. Branch routers, UPS, and printers have no P at all. These are three gaps, all with a U under Tool A. That means the general platform could cover them today with configuration rather than purchase. Certificate expiry has only a secondary, so nobody actually owns it, which is how certificates expire on weekends. And log search is a completely empty row: a genuine capability gap, and a legitimate reason to add something rather than remove it.
That is the whole point of the matrix. In one page it has told this team to keep B and C as specialists and silence C's duplicate alerts. It has told them to decide D's future with a trial and switch on five things A already does. It has also told them to go looking for a log tool. None of those conclusions was available from the tool list alone.
Keeping it alive
An inventory is a snapshot, and estates move. Three habits keep it honest. First, give the matrix an owner, the same way each tool has one. Make updating it part of the checklist for any new hardware, project, or trial: "before this gets a column, who is primary for what?" Second, revisit the rows whenever the device inventory changes. A new device class with no P is a gap from the day it arrives. Third, make the whole thing a scheduled ritual rather than a one-off. The recurring version of this exercise, walking the estate against what is actually watched and classifying every gap, is exactly what coverage reviews describes.
One warning about scope. The temptation, once the matrix exists, is to make it enormous: every metric on every device class. Resist it. The matrix is for decisions. Decisions happen at the level of "who is primary for branch routers," not "who is primary for the inbound discard counter on port 14." Keep rows at the granularity where a change of P would mean a change of tool. Put the fine detail in the tool itself.
Where to go next
With the inventory and matrix in hand, you have the one thing every later step in this series needs. It is a page that says what is watched, by what, and by nothing. Every argument about which tool to keep now has somewhere to point. If you have not yet read how sprawl happens, it explains why the patterns you just found are so common. The next question is what "fewer tools" can honestly look like, which the single pane of glass, dream versus reality answers. After that the consolidation strategy turns your matrix into a sequenced plan. The full series is at Escaping Monitoring Tool Sprawl. And if your column count came out higher than anyone guessed, you are in good company. Eleven was mine.
Put this into practice with SysPeep Monitor
If your matrix shows a column full of U marks under a general platform, that is coverage you already own. In that case, switch it on before you buy anything. If instead the general-platform column is the weak one, SysPeep Monitor is one candidate for that column. It auto-discovers devices and interfaces, and collects over SNMP, WMI and SSH. It puts dashboards, maps, reports and alert rules in one web console. Run the free trial as a fifth column in the matrix and let the P marks decide.
Download Free TrialLearn About SysPeep